News Gambling law

Two schoolchildren swapping trading cards on a bench while a taxman with binoculars peeks over the playground wall

A member of the House of Lords wants to know why buying Pokémon cards isn’t treated as gambling. The Gambling Commission has told him that it isn’t, and that it has no plans to look into it. So is this the start of a new tax on pocket money, or a fair question about where collecting ends and gambling begins?

The challengeLord Foster says that cards with a clear resale value could count as a prize under the Gambling Act.
The answerThe Gambling Commission says that a resale market doesn’t make buying a pack of trading cards gambling.
What happens nextNothing changes unless the government and Parliament change the law.

What Lord Foster asked

Lord Foster chairs Peers for Gambling Reform, a group of members of the House of Lords who campaign for tighter gambling rules. In a letter to the Gambling Commission dated 21 July, first reported by the Pokémon news site Kanto Post, he questioned the regulator’s long-held view that trading cards fall outside the Gambling Act 2005.

His argument rests on two words in the Act. Gaming means playing a game of chance for a prize, and a prize includes “money or money’s worth”. The Commission’s view has been that someone who buys a pack gets cards, not money. Lord Foster’s point is that some cards have an obvious cash value and can be sold through card shops and online marketplaces, entirely legally. He also contrasted them with video game loot boxes, whose contents are usually much harder to sell on, and said that the cards are heavily marketed to children and young people. He called Pokémon “a particularly good case to pursue because there is clear evidence that cash trading does take place”.

He’s not wrong about the money. Last month, a retired decorator from Woking sold the Pokémon collection he’d kept in his attic for around 15 years for £1.56 million at Ewbank’s auction house in Surrey. One set alone, with a near-mint Charizard in it, went for £100,000.

What the Gambling Commission said

The Commission’s acting chief executive, Sarah Gardner, replied on 11 August. She said that the fact that cards can be sold on later doesn’t, by itself, make selling them gambling, and that Parliament never meant the Act to cover trading cards or football stickers just because there’s an element of chance in what you get. She also pointed out that treating them as gambling could stop young people from enjoying their hobby, or even criminalise them for it, and that Parliament can’t have intended that either.

She did leave room for one exception. The Commission can look at products that build overtly gambling-like features into what would otherwise be a shopping platform. But she said that it isn’t currently doing any work on the buying or trading of collectable cards or stickers, and that any change to the definition of gambling is for the government and Parliament to decide.

Is this just another way to tax us?

I can understand why that’s the first thing many people will think. Gambling has been taxed hard over the last two years. Online casino tax went from 21% to 40% in April, betting duty goes to 25% next April, and the duty on gaming machines rises too. Even prize draws have been complaining about their tax bills this year. When someone suggests classing yet another thing as “gambling”, it’s natural to wonder whether the Treasury is behind it.

This time, though, it isn’t. Lord Foster is a Liberal Democrat peer and a long-standing campaigner, not a government minister, and his letter is about protecting children, not raising money. There’s no sign that the Treasury or the Department for Culture, Media and Sport has any interest in it, and the regulator has already said no.

More to the point, classing card packs as gambling wouldn’t raise much tax anyway. Gambling duties are charged on licensed operators’ profits, and nobody would be licensed to sell gambling to children. The likely result would be an age limit on packs, not a new revenue stream. The Treasury already takes its cut in the normal way, through VAT on every pack sold, just as it does on any other toy or game.

Will taxmen be searching children’s pockets for a rare Pokémon?

No. Nobody is going to frisk a Year 5 pupil for a shiny Charizard. A child’s card collection is just a collection of personal possessions, and selling one isn’t a taxable event for most people. Under the existing capital gains rules, a single item or set sold for £6,000 or less is exempt. Big sales, like that £1.56 million auction, can already fall into the tax system if the gains are large enough, and that has nothing to do with gambling law.

The real risk to children is the one that Sarah Gardner raised. Under the Gambling Act, it’s an offence for a 16- or 17-year-old to gamble, outside a few exceptions. If buying a booster pack counted as gambling, a teenager picking one up at the newsagent could, in theory, be breaking the law. That’s absurd, and it’s why the regulator was right to say that this needs Parliament’s attention rather than a creative reading of the existing Act.

It’s also worth remembering that “gambling” doesn’t automatically mean “adults only” in Britain. Children can legally play coin pushers and crane grabbers at the seaside, because the lowest category of gaming machine has no minimum age. The law already draws these lines with some care, and stretching it to cover every pack of cards would do more harm than good.

Where Lord Foster does have a point

If you stop at the newsagent’s booster pack, this whole debate looks a bit silly. But that’s not where the market is any more. Kanto Post has also looked at “repacks” and “mystery slabs”, where sellers put a few valuable, professionally graded cards into a pool with lots of cheaper ones and charge anything from around £30 to several hundred pounds for a random pull. Some sellers outside the UK will even buy your card back for cash or credit straight away. Dr Leon Xiao, a researcher who studies loot boxes and trading cards, told the site that he considers some of these products to be unlicensed gambling, and that UK retailers selling them would be breaching gambling law.

That’s much closer to the kind of gambling-like shopping platform that Sarah Gardner said the Commission could look at. When you’re paying £100 for a random chance at a card worth more or less than £100, and the seller offers to turn your result straight into cash, it’s hard to see much difference from a scratchcard. Xiao’s research, which is still awaiting peer review, also found that 80% of the trading card products he looked at didn’t show any odds at all. Odds disclosure, and age limits on the expensive mystery products, would be a sensible place to start, without touching the pocket-money end of the hobby.

The bigger question of how to define gambling is coming anyway. The new Gambling Policy Commission, an independent body that’s asking whether Britain needs a new Gambling Act, opened its call for evidence this month, and what counts as gambling is exactly the kind of question it could take on. Lord Foster would like it to; he says that the 2020 House of Lords report on gambling, which he worked on, recommended changing the definition. Back in 2022, the government decided against bringing loot boxes under the Gambling Act and asked the games industry to regulate itself. Don’t expect it to move faster on cardboard character cards.

So, are trading cards going to be classed as gambling?

Not ordinary packs, and not any time soon. The regulator has said no, the government hasn’t shown any interest, and the law would have to change before anything else could happen. This isn’t a tax grab, and there won’t be any taxmen in the playground.

But I wouldn’t dismiss Lord Foster’s letter, either. The part of the market that sells expensive random pulls for cash, often without telling buyers their odds, looks a lot like gambling, and that’s the part that deserves a closer look. Leave the children’s swaps alone, and ask the people selling £100 lucky dips to show their workings. That seems like a fair deal for everyone.